Variant Matters
Normal, Golden, Diamond and Rainbow versions of the same pet are separate rows. Make sure the variant in the trade window matches the one you are pricing.
Secret Tiers
Secret I to Secret X pets are the main trading currency. Use the value score to compare across tiers instead of relying on the tier name alone.
Low Supply Pets
Leaderboard and release pets have tiny supplies. Their values can move sharply on a single trade, so double-check recent trends before buying or selling.